|
>View discussions about this entry País: United States
Organization: RugMark USA
Sector Focus - Business
Year the initative began (yyyy) - 1996
YouTube Upload - Place your video embed code here from YouTube, Google Video and other video sharing websites. How to embed a video from YouTube.
Project URL: http://www.rugmark.org/home.php
Positioning in the Mosaic of solutions
What is your signature innovation, your new idea, in one sentence? - RugMark's innovation is to remove the market demand for child-made goods and raise the financial cost of using illegal child labor in carpet manufacture.
Describe your innovation. What makes your idea unique and different than others doing work in the field? - The movement to end child labor has developed over more than a century and includes thousands of agencies. Many work to erect and advocate a legal infrastructure that protects children, such as ratifying conventions on Minimum Age and Worst Forms.
In every carpet-producing country where RugMark operates, national laws dictate the conditions under which child labor is illegal. While governments don’t consistently enforce these laws, markets can. RugMark addresses the two factors that truly perpetuate child labor: its invisibility and profitability. It’s difficult to notice children hidden in dark loom sheds and it’s difficult to convince manufacturers not to employ the cheapest labor possible. RugMark shines a light on this inhumane practice; creates a transparent trading system through an inspection and monitoring system on the ground; identifies slavery-free goods with its certification label; and rescues, rehabilitates and educates former victims. The innovation includes a self-financing component: a percentage of sales of certified child-labor-free rugs are invested back into the work of ending child slavery. Delivery Model: How do you implement your innovation and apply it to the challenge/problem you are addressing? - RugMark USA ensures that no one can profit from or claim ignorance of this injustice through its Most Beautiful Rug consumer awareness campaign. The goal is that everyone who sets out to buy a hand-woven rug is informed of the RugMark option. Through a combination of strategies including advertising, branding, media outreach, event participation, point-of-sale materials, and an online presence, RugMark offers manufacturers of certified child-labor-free rugs preferential treatment and enhanced visibility in the American marketplace.
How do you plan to grow your innovation? - Today 2.1 percent of rugs imported to the U.S. carry the RugMark® label. With The Most Beautiful Rug campaign, RugMark aims to double its market share in 2008 and hit 7 percent by 2009. Ultimately, RugMark believes it can reach 15 percent within the next decade, the estimated tipping point to end child servitude industry-wide in South Asia.
In the coming year, increased attention will be paid to the industry’s most influential players, including engaging the largest national retailers of handmade rugs, as well as the interior design community and sales associates. The other expansion will be of RugMark’s international network with feasibility studies in two new producer countries slated to begin. Since the demand for certified rugs has met supply, RugMark will need to look for new ways to grow in the market. Finally, RugMark USA is launching a process this year to document the learning from its model and look for ways to replicate it in other industries plagued by exploitative labor practices. Do you have any existing partnerships, and if so, how do you create them? - RugMark's innovation relies upon private sector partnerships. This includes RugMark’s 50 importer licensees and more than 1,000 showrooms and retail outlets. When rug companies become licensees, inspectors in South Asia gain access to looms and factories, enabling the rescue and deterrence of more children from exploitation and generating more funds to support schooling for former carpet kids.
In RugMark’s first organizational phase, companies that joined the certification program were mainly compelled by a moral imperative. RugMark USA’s current business development strategy involves one-on-one business outreach, tradeshow participation and other activities engaged to convince more companies driven by the profit motive. RugMark also counts some eight media companies as sponsors of The Most Beautiful Rug campaign. Sponsors run dedicated public service advertising, and assist in other ways to build RugMark’s brand awareness. Prospective media partners were identified through extensive demographic research and priority was given to those most likely to reach the largest numbers of individuals who could effect change in the carpet industry: rug purchasers. Provide one sentence describing your impact/intended impact. - Market share growth of RugMark certified rugs means children being educated not exploited, companies converting to an ethical supply chain and consumers making principled purchases.
How many people have you served or plan to serve? - In RugMark’s first decade, child labor decreased by as much as 60 percent in the carpet belt of South Asia (from 1 million to 300,000). Today, over 3,000 children are enrolled in RugMark rehabilitation or education programs in India and Nepal.
RugMark has estimated that for every percentage point market share earned, 750 children are rescued from the workplace, 1,000 are saved from entering, and 2,200 jobs are given to adults rather than children.
Please list any other measures of the impact of your innovation? - RugMark measures impact using various indicators:
Market growth – market share data, number of licensees and participating retailers. Consumer awareness – number of advertising, editorial and website hits and consumers reached; awareness year-on-year; retail sales of certified rugs. Social impact -- incidence of inspectors finding children; dollars raised for children’s education; number of children studying with RugMark support. Signs that RugMark is realizing its vision include: market growth rate; widespread availability of certified rugs; quantity and quality of partnerships; and involvement of major retailers.
Exactly who are the beneficiaries of your innovation? - RugMark serves South Asia’s quarter million ‘carpet kids’ by removing them from slave-like conditions, reuniting them with family, and raising funds for their rehabilitation and education.
RugMark fosters integrity in an industry critical for the literal and cultural survival of countless people. While overall sales of handmade rugs declined in 2007, sales of RugMark certified carpets increased 20%, keeping more adult artisans employed. RugMark offers the millions of conscious consumers independent verification that their rug was manufactured in a humanitarian fashion. How is your initiative financed (or how do you expect your initiative will be financed)? - In 2008, RugMark’s funding is as follows: charitable donations represent 51% of projected revenue, industry payments 26%, in-kind services 22%, and interest the rest.
Ultimately RugMark believes that industry should pay for its own regulation. Importers pay RugMark USA a 1.75 percent royalty on the net import value of carpet shipments on a quarterly basis. Sixty percent of these fees support the rehabilitation, education and social welfare programs that RugMark provides in South Asia. The remainder is dedicated to market development for child-labor-free rugs. RugMark’s licensing fees, totaling $187,000 in 2007, have grown by 34% over the past three years. Sales of RugMark rugs since 2000 have generated over a half million dollars to assist and educate victims and those at risk of becoming enslaved. If known, provide information on your finances and organization - Annual budget;
Annual revenue generated; Number of staff: ESTIMATED 2008 REVENUE AND EXPENSE $1 ,571,387 RugMark has secured approximately 87 percent of its charitable revenue for the year and has $100,000 still to raise. An anonymous donor has agreed to match new money, dollar for dollar, up to $50,000 in 2008. Full-time staff: 6 What is the potential demand for your innovation? - A former child weaver in India, Asha, recently told RugMark: “Tell them, tell everyone, not to buy goods made by kids.” This sentiment demonstrates the urgent and ongoing demand for RugMark.
As the green economy and overseas manufacturing escalates, companies will increasingly turn to groups that offer third-party verification, market positioning and risk mitigation. RugMark’s model has already inspired initiatives in other industries and has been cited as an example for companies like Gap struggling to ensure a slavery-free supply chain. What are the main barriers to financial sustainability? - Financial sustainability will be hastened as more and bigger companies join RugMark. RugMark’s licensing fees, totaling $187,000 in 2007, have grown by 34 percent over the past three years. Today, 17 percent of RugMark’s budget is covered by licensee payments and by yearend, this is projected to reach 45 percent. In 2010, RugMark anticipates that industry revenue will supersede charitable gifts. This would be a significant milestone, one that few nonprofits realize and even fewer in a decade of opening its doors.
What is the origin of this innovation? Tell us your story. - By the 1980s, after the release of several revealing studies by the U.S. Department of Labor and human rights groups, the carpet industry had earned worldwide notoriety for its use of child labor. Moral outrage alone was not going to end child exploitation and the looming threat of an international boycott would have only hurt indigenous weaving communities.
In 1994, a coalition of NGOs throughout South Asia led by Indian activist and Ashoka fellow Kailash Satyarthi, looked to the businesses and shoppers of the West. After decades of rescuing children from bonded labor only to see them replaced by others, it was time to instigate a change in the market. They created a label for handmade rugs produced without illegal child labor: the RugMark®. RugMark now operates in five countries under an international affiliate network structure. As the world’s largest market for handmade rugs, the U.S. has the greatest potential and responsibility to address the injustices in this $1.2 billion retail industry. RugMark USA opened its doors in 1999 with the hiring of the first staff person, Nina Smith. While most brands launch with a multi-million dollar campaign, RugMark USA spent less than $1 million and had only a two-person staff in its first five years. Nevertheless today over 2 percent of the handmade rugs brought into the U.S. carry the RugMark® label. This domestic market growth brought results overseas. In 12 years of operation, child labor in the industry decreased by as much as two-thirds. Please provide a personal bio. Note this may be used in Changemakers marketing material - Nina Smith is the founding Executive Director of RugMark USA, a nonprofit-business hybrid combating exploitative child labor in South Asia’s handmade rug industry. A fair trade advocate and marketing professional for 15 years, Nina was recipient of the Skoll Award for Social Entrepreneurship in 2005. Nina was formerly the Executive Director of The Crafts Center and President of the Fair Trade Federation. Her overseas experience includes a crafts development consultancy to the fair trade company The Tibet Collection in India.
Contact Information:
Nina Smith
Executive Director RugMark USA (NGO) Discussions about this entry |

On July 16, 2008, the judges reviewed the entries for the Changemakers “Ending Global Slavery” Competition and would like to pass on the following feedback for your entry. Thank you for applying and for your hard work in the field. We are excited to archive your entry to serve as a leading solution for the worldwide community of innovators who are exposing, confronting and ending modern day slavery. We wish you continued luck with your sustainable, innovative, and socially impactful initiatives.
All the best, The Changemakers Team
“This initiative creates a brand designed on the concept of treating people humanely. It is a hopeful call-to-action that has the potential for scale and replication across sectors.”
“This model is truly innovative in that it works to eliminate the market demand for carpets made by children. It also has great potential to spread to other industries. We are interested in learning more about potential partnership opportunities with other companies as the initiative expands in the future.”
“This initiative combines pragmatism with real social impact by harnessing globalization—often a force blamed for human trafficking—and utilizing it to promote human rights.”
- Changemakers “Ending Global Slavery” Judges: United Nations Global Initiative to Fight Trafficking, International Organization for Migration, Design Within Reach, Vital Voices Global Partnership, Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, Humanity United.
----------
The Changemakers Team
Ashoka's Changemakers
Hi Nina,
Are Rugmark rugs more expensive? If so, by how much? Who are the largest national retailers of handmade rugs? Who are the eight media companies that are sponsoring your campaign?
Have you heard of Carpets for Communities? You may be interested in checking out their entry. I think they could certainly benefit from your knowledge of the field and from your experience. They are smaller and working on expansion. Check out their entry and feel free to offer them any feedback or support: http://www.changemakers.net/node/8413
Keep up the great work!
Dana
Hi Dana,
Good questions -- If a company passes along the actual cost of RugMark participation onto the consumer, the added cost to a rug is half of one percent of the retail price (.05%). So on a $2,000 rug the added cost of the RugMark is about $10.
The largest retailers of handmade rugs include Macy's, Inc., ABC Carpet & Home and William & Sonoma, among others. Our campaign media sponsors are listed on our home page at www.rugmark.org and include Dwell, California Home & Design, Interior Design, Western Interiors & Design, Apartment Therapy, Conscious Living Media, Yoga Journal and Modern Luxury Publishing Group. These media outlets reach millions of our target audience: interior designers and high-end consumers shopping for rugs (as well as those who make their purchases according to their personal values).
Thanks for the link to Carpets for Communities.
Nina
Dear Ms. Smith-
I just finished reading your entry and it sounds like you are doing amazing work. Trafficking of person- regardless of the motive- is a notorious high profit low risk enterprise for traffickers and it is great to see such a solid program working to increase the opportunity costs for traffickers. Great job. I wonder if you could share with us some of the criteria you use to inspect and monitor companies on the ground to ensure they are not using child laborers- is the same criteria you use to decide which of these companies get the Rug Mark seal?
Thank you!
Laura Cardinal
Public Health and Human Trafficking Specialist
Hi Laura,
Thanks for your comments and questions. Since the process of licensing and inspection under RugMark's system is fairly complex, I will try to give you some top-line information, and then let me know if you want more. The companies that buy and sell rugs with our certification are called licensees. We license the importer (or brand) and corresponding exporter(s) who oversee (and sometimes own) production. Importer licensees sign a contract agreeing to source product from only licensed exporters in the countries where we operate. Exporter licensees sign a contract agreeing to comply with the RugMark standard of not employing children 14 years or younger or any forced or bonded labor. Exporters agree to random, surprise inspections at their loom sites, which they update bi-annually. There is a detailed process of inspection, carried out by rotating teams, that involves completing detailed reports about the workers on site, the rugs on loom, information gathered through interviews, and documentation of wage book and purchase order information. Sometimes children are identified. Inspectors are trained to look for signs of possible hidden child labor, such as an empty spot at a loom. Looms suspected of concealing child labor receive more frequent, repeat visits. In addition, spot checks are made once a week to cross check inspector reports, ensuring loom visits took place. Companies with no child labor violations against them are issued certifcation labels. The labels are individually numbered and can be traced back to the loom or factory location.
When children are found, they are offered a range of rehabilitation options, however it is their choice whether to accept. We offer center-based rehabilitation where they can live and study, or community-based rehabilitation whereby they return home and attend school with RugMark support.
Please let me know if/where you would like to delve deeper.
Thanks for your interest -- Nina
While it is illegal to import slave made items into the US, the reality is that there is no way to tell if that shirt you are wearing was made by a slave or not. RugMark's work is vital because and has lead to significant reduction in the use of slaves for rug production. It would be great to see this kind of work spread into other products.
I hope anyone reading this remembers what RugMark does, so that the next time they are in a rug store they can ask if they sell slave free rugs. As consumers we also have our role to play in making sure stores know we will only buy slave free products.
----------
John Berger
The Emancipation Network
http://www.madebysurvivors.com/